Opinion: Why All the Noise?

by | Apr 9, 2024

Above: A crew of leaf blowers on Vine Street in December 2021.

Imagine I am your neighbor and I am in a rock band. My band likes to practice outside on my patio a few times a week for two to three hours. How long do you think this would last? A week, a few minutes before a complaint was made and I was forced to stop or change what I was doing? How long before neighbors on the other street would notice? A few streets away, etc. You get the point, now bear in mind the average rock band produces between 90 to 120 decibels. Now consider the noise from one backpack leaf-blower ranges from 64 to 78 decibels at 50 feet. At the operator’s ear, the noise is 95 to 115 decibels. A commercial lawn mower averages 80 to 95 decibels at the user and another 60 to 75 at 50 feet. Stats you can google. The average landscaper uses at times two to three leaf blowers, a commercial lawn mower, and other tools. So the decibel levels to a close neighbor are quite loud and the noise certainly carries. So why is this accepted at frequent intervals, several days a week for several hours at a time?

Now two things I would like to make clear. First of all, this is a privileged problem to complain about, a real first world problem. But a problem many face with growing frequency. Secondly, it is important to state this is not a dig or complaint leveled at Landscapers and their crews. These are small business owners who work very hard and employ hard working individuals. They are in fact just doing their best on a job they were hired to due. No fault there.

Now the frustration. As the warmer weather approaches so do the landscapers. I have been witnessing a rise in the number of landscapers and their visits in my neighborhood over the past few years. But more importantly is a sustained frequency of visits, growing to the point of weekly. Last summer I marked a period of 6 to 8 weeks with at least one landscaper, sometimes two or three, for three or more days a week with an average of 3 hours each day for the period. This is a tremendous amount and the noise from multiple leaf blowers, mowers and equipment is often overwhelming. Think back to the annoying neighbor with the rock band. This has been brought up in the past with no resolution. What possible solutions are there? Is it possible to have a run time limit, a number of backpacks per yard limit? Can a dB levels be looked into? What can be done to protect citizens who are subject to such noise pollution and duration of said noise? Where is the balance between the work getting done and neighbors ability to enjoy peace?

I do not use a service and am frustrated with my diminished level of peace and quiet, also my ability to enjoy my own property and environment. As a taxpayer, I should have the ability to enjoy my property understanding there will be the occasional distribution (understanding that fall and spring clean ups and individual residents who do their own yard work occur). There are days I can’t even go outside and enjoy my own yard. I have the good fortune to stay home with my two sons in the summer and often times we are captives in our own homes or most often we have to leave our house to get away from it. There is one landscaper who in the summer is here on my street every week, for a minimum of 4 to 5 hours. These are the days we all sigh and have to shut in or leave for the day.

I often wonder, is there a way to limit the frequency and number of jobs per neighborhood? Perhaps a system if you will like garbage pick up where they can work ion certain streets/neighborhoods on odd or even weeks. Also, do they need to come every week? I have witnessed mowers mowing dirt during the drought last summer. Homes were getting unnecessarily mowed every week while I mowed every three to four weeks. I understand the need for the companies to make money and employ workers but at what expense? If left unchecked, the landscapers can’t be blamed, they are trying to make money and keep growing their business. Why wouldn’t they hire more workers, get more equipment to get more jobs done faster? I would submit why am I and other taxpayers subjected to such high noise levels and disruptions at increased frequency for longer amounts of time? This has been a steady growing problem the last few years. Having been a resident for over 10 years I can think back a few years when I wouldn’t have been bothered, but there has been quite a steady and significant rise in the noise levels.

I have seriously considered moving as it is so frustrating and bothersome. This growing problem has severely limiting my ability to enjoy my own property. At what point do other members of the community have a right to say enough with the noise?

I would encourage any community members who feel similarly to contact the Town Council to look for a mutually beneficial resolution. 

Christopher Flanagan is a resident of East Greenwich.

Value the news you get here on East Greenwich News? As a 501-c3, we depend on reader support. Become a sustaining (monthly) donor or make a one-time donation! Click on the Donate button below or send a check to EG News, 18 Prospect St., East Greenwich, RI 02818. Thanks.

Subscribe
Notify of
guest

20 Comments
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Peter
Peter
April 9, 2024 8:29 pm

I completely agree with this. It’s constant where we live, and still well audible indoors with the windows closed. Common sense regulations around hours (not fun eating outdoors after 7pm in the summer and having to yell over the noise) would be a start but changes need to go further than that.

Chris
Chris
April 9, 2024 8:35 pm

I choose to have my yard mowed, edged and blown every 2 weeks instead of weekly most of the year, and the world still turns. The lawn gets a little long in the spring months but it’s good for it, saves me $200 a month, and saves me and the neighbors at least one “flight of the bumblebees” played on 11 a week.

The blowers are not only obnoxiously loud, they are dirty 2 cycle machines, and do a worse job at everything other than blowing off the hardscapes than a good ol quiet and clean rake that costs $15.

Ray Riccio
Ray Riccio
April 9, 2024 9:26 pm

I was going to refrain but,
Imagine waking up to a couple or three loud paperboys delivering the morning Providence Journal at 4:00am so they could go dig the tide at 5:00-5:30am. Opening your window complaining, yelling to these yewts, punks to SHUT THE $@&? UP.

And in response these yewts, punks yelling back “our complaint department manager is Helen Waite, if you have a complaint go to Helen Waite.”

Better yet living in a house where Pierce & Liberty Streets split. A favorite spot where these yewts, punks would practice 3 or so times a week at night preparing for the battle of the bands to be held in the parking lot of the Lutheran Church or inside what is now the Community Center. At least 15 yewts, punks at that house during these times, fights, running from the law some hiding out in your backyard. Is that you Riccio? Who you hiding out from now?

Or closing off Liberty Street to have a reunion of all those yewts, punks that growed up in EG reminiscing about what I just explained.

10 years? Yeah ok. I hope you do find peace here or somewhere else and if it’s somewhere else, take the people that crowd this town, the streets, the waterfront with cars, boats, loud music, over build, drive drunk on the streets, forced those that growed up in those houses down by the bay to move or sell and take them with you then maybe all that noise you hear will dissipate.

Yeah that noise, I sure do miss it.

Oh and don’t expect this TC to listen. They’ll tell you the same thing those paperboys yelled back at 4:00am.

Erik Nelson
Erik Nelson
April 10, 2024 8:11 am

Thank you Christopher! This leaf blowers are the real problem – it we can get very specific and just chip away at that, maybe the town can do something – I sent multiple complaints, Leaf blowers are awful (not just dB but the pitch/intensity and hours) – there is no other serious offensive noise in the neighborhood in my opinion and 100s of towns across the country are now banning gas/propane bowered leaf blowers. Also, there is no ”slippery slope” argument (the town will try this, did in an email to me) to other equipment like trimmers – it is really a leaf blower problem.

Leaf blowers also go on for 4-5 hours at a time, sometimes non-stop entire day. Very different than emergency chain saws etc.  It greatly effects our quality of life her in EG. I don’t have the same issue w/ mowers. Lets ban powerful leaf blowers as a community.

What can I do to get this back on the town agenda? Banning gas powered Leaf blowers and added to noise pollution? Also It is not currently under “exceptions” in the noise code under 152-6, so my interpretation is it violates the code as well.

Christopher
Christopher
April 10, 2024 12:32 pm
Reply to  Erik Nelson

Agreed. Some towns have place a Summertime ban on leaf blowers. That might be a good balance. There is no real reason to run them May through September.

Kate W.
Kate W.
April 13, 2024 6:09 am
Reply to  Christopher

That’s a great idea!

bgwar
bgwar
April 10, 2024 8:48 am

The gas-powered engines of these leaf blowers emit A LOT of exhaust – pulled from a GBH article, see link below: “‘A commercial landscaper using one backpack leaf blower for one hour generates the same smog-forming emissions as a car driving 1,100 miles,’ according to California’s Air Resources Board.”
Solutions should be at the state level with phase out with incentives to support the move to electric powered.
https://www.wgbh.org/news/local/2023-11-09/why-gas-powered-leaf-blowers-are-getting-banned-in-greater-boston

Christopher
Christopher
April 10, 2024 1:36 pm
Reply to  bgwar

I think a reasonable start would be to limit them during the Summer months and Sundays as well. Another option is on and off weeks for services. The combo could prove quite effective while still allowing services. Focusing on the Blowers as they are the biggest issue. Landscapers could opt for Electric.
I do think folks need to start banning together and start a Citizens group to address this.

Chris
Chris
April 10, 2024 10:06 am

Can we start with no lawn companies doing work on Sundays?

Virgie
Virgie
April 10, 2024 10:10 am

“There is one landscaper who in the summer is here on my street every week, for a minimum of 4 to 5 hours. These are the days we all sigh and have to shut in or leave for the day.”
This is absolutely ridiculous. I dislike these things as well but do not have to put up with it to this degree.
A rake..hah!! Ain’t no way that’s gonna happen. Anyway, sorry for the “ruination” of your peace and quiet.

George
George
April 10, 2024 10:30 am

If you insist/believe that gas-powered leaf blowers are “essential” to lawncare service, then you have to insist/believe that no lawncare service was ever provided prior to the mid-1970s. These devices are awful and should be banned. Electric-powered ones are bad enough, but gas-powered ones are dinosaurs.

Bob
Bob
April 10, 2024 11:30 am

OMG what has happened to East Greenwich with all these complainers?? Don’t you have anything better to do? You would be the first to call the town when their properties were unkept and not pristine. They would complain about their property values declining. Please stop!

Chris
Chris
April 10, 2024 5:32 pm
Reply to  Bob

Bob, no compromise, no empathy? Why is it one way or no way? Did you read it? Or just figured it’s the same thing? And if so that tells you more people have issues with it than you think. It has to do solely with noise created by one piece of equipment, nothing “complaining” about Landscapers. If the neighbors dog crapped on your lawn everyday you would complain.

Bob
Bob
April 11, 2024 10:04 am
Reply to  Chris

I did read it, thanks. So, what is next, my lawn mower, weed wacker, the car I drive or maybe what I have for dinner. There are soooo many problems in EG beyond this nonsense. Does the noise of cars from Rt. 4 bother you also? Maybe as Mr. Riccio states it’s time the younger generation grows up and start minding your own business. The only one crapping on my rights is you and your friends. Find a hobby. Again, Please stop and grow up! Boy do I miss the Ole EG!

Cara
Cara
April 10, 2024 11:56 am

The first lawn care company to invest in offering electric leaf blower service will be very very busy.

Lindsay
Lindsay
April 11, 2024 6:31 am

Here is a link to a local RI organization seeking to address this issue statewide, in Providence and Barrington. https://quietcleanri.org/about-us/

I have recently been mowing my lawn with a traditional reel lawn mower and raking leaves by hand. It has been a joyous way to deepen my connection to the beauty of the natural world and care for those who live around me.

Lisa P.
Lisa P.
April 11, 2024 4:16 pm

Thank you for that article! Having moved to EG from a community where gas-powered leaf blowers were banned by city ordinance, I have been so disgusted with the number and frequency of the use of them here in this beautiful town, and shocked at how often I see a team of 3 landscapers using them as a squadron to tame the leaves in the huge yards. What a racket! There is a recent article by ecoRINews that explains some of the reasons why the cities and the state can’t seem to get a ban passed: https://ecori.org/gas-powered-leaf-blowers-need-to-go/. There are great electric leaf blowers out there so giving incentives to existing landscape companies to switch over might help.. But we need to get the town to pass an ordinance.

Bob
Bob
April 12, 2024 9:26 am
Reply to  Lisa P.

I’m sure the town will reimburse me for the $400 I paid for my backpack gas blower to take care of my property, or maybe you can compensate me? Are the EG police going to come and handcuff me when I use my blower? Just asking.

Kate W.
Kate W.
April 12, 2024 7:24 am

I agree we need to put some limits. For the past few years, I have told our landscaper just to cut the lawn and edge the front curb (no blowers!) and it’s been fine. I like the idea of having them come every other week instead of weekly. Thanks for stating the discussion again!

Berta
Berta
April 13, 2024 10:33 am

I think it’s really funny this this wasn’t an issue pre-Covid. Now that everyone has decided to continue to “work-from-home”, the lawn maintenance companies, which provide a well needed service, are an issue. Those who were at home (stay at home parents and retirees, etc) pre-covid didn’t complain. As the article stated its a privilege problem. I can’t afford a lawn maintenance service, but I do mow my own lawn and use a leaf blower!

My son’s band practiced in our driveway during Covid and people complained, so we applied for a noise ordnance. People complained about music being played for 1-2 hours on a Monday evening (5-7pm) . The local kids came and sat in our yard and enjoyed a free mini-concert, neighbors texted about how much they improved. FYI- they just released their second album on Spotify, if you are interested search Appala’s Eclipse.

So, i grew up in this town, as did my parents. My siblings and I also chose to raise our families here. It’s not the same anymore. Please people, enjoy our little town, let people do what they need to do.. stop interfering in other’s lives and be happy your neighbor keeps their lawn and yard looking nice. With the new evaluations, it’s better for you to have a neighbor who maintains their yard, verses those who don’t.

RELATED STORIES

Newsletter Sign Up

* indicates required

Archives

Latest Streaming