Who Was Dr. James H. Eldredge?

by | Jan 8, 2021

I was going to write a piece on Dr. Eldredge for EG News and the EG Then & Now Face Book page but this was so much better, I decided to go with Dr. Turner’s eulogy to his friend. So, I offer this in with deference to a man who knew him better. I could have brought the language more up-to-date but they wrote so much more eloquently in the late 1800s. Fight your way through it and see what we miss. Alas, we couldn’t possibly write this way today. 

Portrait of Dr James H. Eldredge, local physician late 1800s. School named after him.

James Henry Eldredge was born 27 May 1816 in East Greenwich in the house on the corner of Division and Peirce Streets where he lived all of his life, and died there 20 February 1892. He was educated at Kent [aka East Greenwich] Academy and went on to study medicine, returning to R.I. after getting his degree in 1837 to assist his father, Dr. Charles Eldredge, who died the following year leaving him with a large practice in which he continued for over 50 years. For 20 years he was Consulting Physician to Rhode Island Hospital; for 40 years he was a member of the local school committee serving as president for 20 years; member of the town council, State Legislature, R.I. Medical Society, etc. The James H. Eldredge School was named in his honor. In 1922 his two granddaughters had a Wayside Cross erected to his memory. Once it was at the corner of Division Road and Route 2 but it is now located just inside the cemetery at the corner of Cedar Avenue and Middle Road. 

Dr. Henry E. Turner (1816 – 1897) was the grandson of Dr. Peter Turner, the Revolutionary War surgeon whose house was at 21 Court House Lane, and miraculously, it still is. Dr. Turner eventually moved to Newport but he spent his youth in East Greenwich and Dr. James H. Eldredge was a good friend and later a colleague in the medical profession. Dr. Charles Eldredge, his son Dr. James Henry Eldredge, and Dr. Turner were all leaders of the Rhode Island Medical Society in their times. Dr. Turner outlived Dr. James Eldredge and delivered this tribute to his friend at a meeting of the R. I. Medical Society. This then, is probably the best we can know about why Eldredge School is named thus:

Obituary of Dr. James Henry Eldredge

By Dr. Henry E. Turner, March 1891

Having, for nearly three quarters of a Century, been associated in the most intimate manner with our late friend and Fellow, Doctor James. H. Eldredge, it has been suggested by some of our friends, that it was incumbent on me to bring before the Society, of which we have both been members for more than a half century, (I having been admitted a Member in 1837 and Dr. Eldredge the succeeding year, when the Presidential chair was occupied by his honored father, Dr. Charles Eldredge of East Greenwich), a tribute of affection and of respect, to which his memory is most justly entitled, and not withstanding my extreme diffidence of my capacity to do full justice to the subject so near to me heart, and so should be a melancholy pleasure. Trusting to your forebearance if my effort does not come up to the high standard to which you have a right to expect, in view of your high appreciation of the transcendent merits of our common friends, I proceed to the performance of the obligation.

Dr. Henry Turner

The sphere of action of a physician in a rural district, comprising only moderate sized villages within its limits, is not such a field as affords opportunities or inducements for the sensational methods by which great reputations are frequently made in large cities, and no startling and exceptionally brilliant effects are produced on the public mind by the phenomenally successful results which sometimes follow, on reckless adventures in the domain of surgery. We therefore, must content ourselves with a contemplation, in the professional career of our friend, of a life spent in the conscientious and diligent and extremely laborious service of a clientele, not, as a whole, capable of a liberal, not to say elegant, compensation, but the opposite, for the fifty three years, in a faithful, conscientious and laborious manner, always at his post, in season and out of season, always preserving the bland and suave address that characterized

him, under whatever provocation, and retaining to his last moments almost without exception the esteem and affection of the community in which he lived. Although conservative in his methods, and the character of his mind, Dr., Eldredge was diligent in the study of current professional literature, and extremely solicitous that nothing promising benefit to his patients should be overlooked or neglected, and the estimate made of him by his employers proves that they appreciated these traits of character, and believed in their materialization.

Dr. Eldredge was born on the twenty-seventh of May, 1816, in East Greenwich in the same house in which he died and from which he was carried to his grave. His father was Dr. Charles Eldredge who had practiced medicine with great success in East Greenwich during all his active life, and who also died in the same house in which his son, the Doctor, was born and died.

Dr. Charles Eldredge was born in Eastern Connecticut, and was the son of James Eldredge, who was a Captain in the Continental line of the American Army in the Revolution, and they were of a good old New England stock. Dr. Charles prosecuted his studies in Connecticut and graduated in medicine at Yale College, and in my earliest recollection stood very high in his profession, and was a leading figure in all matters of a social or financial or political character in and about Greenwich, being for several years in the State Senate, when quite a young man. The mother of Dr. George McLellan, the father of General George B. McLellan, U.S.A. was the sister of Dr. C. Eldredge, and when attending lectures in Philadelphia, Dr. James H. was a student of Dr. George McLellan, his cousin, and graduated at Jefferson College, in which Dr. George and his brother, Samnuel McLellan, were, at the time (1838) Professors.

Dr. James H. received his early instruction in the Academy at East Greenwich, and afterward passed some years at the School of Mr. Charles Greene, at Jamaica Plains, near Boston. His father died not long after his graduation, and he immediately succeeded to his practice, which had been extensive and absorbing, and exposing and laborious to the last degree, as it continued to be. Dr. James became, as his father had been, not only the professional advisor, but the confidential and business friend and advisor to large numbers of his neighbors, and in his later days enjoyed a kind of Patriarchal relationship with the people of the locality. For many years he was a Member and Secretary of the School Committee, and for about twenty its President, for two years he was a Member of the State Senate, but he did not political preferment, and held no other State office. He was at the time of his death President of the Town Council.

Dr. Eldredge’s character as a boy at school, the period at which my knowledge of him was close and constant, there were no recollections of differences with other boys, such as generally interrupt boyish intimacies, with occasional storms. I could not expect to recall any such, in detail, if they occurred but there would have been left some impression of such a possibility, which there is not. He was a clever fellow with all the boys, without qualification, and those are the recollections which belong with and are part of his memory, with all his early associates, and in these particulars the boy was father to the man.

Though of Puritan stock, the three generations to whom I have referred, were all Episcopalians and Dr. James’s religious sentiments were very strong and abiding. His father was very active and largely instrumental in establishing the Episcopal Church in East Greenwich in 1830, or thereabouts, and his son was very earnest and active and efficient in the erection of the present beautiful structure, and in the present flourishing conditions of its affairs. The church building to which I allude is a gem, in its way, and a superb monument of the good taste and correct religious sentiment of the community, and particularly of the generation of which Dr. Eldredge was a leading figure.

For myself, I can say that my recollection, which is very distinct from 1820, affords no suggestion of any even momentary interruption to our close and continuous friendship.

On Dr. Eldredge’s relations to this Society, I need not dwell at any length, they are familiar to you all. For fifty years, he was very seldom absent at the meetings of the Society. For very many years, and at his decease, he was one of your censors, and was always a faithful member, and deeply interested in whatever pertained to the welfare and credit of the Society. His judgment was always thoroughly appreciated, and his suggestions always listened to with the utmost deference and they were generally fraught with that degree of wisdom which warranted that deference. Dr. Eldredge was a Vice President of the Society from 1854 to 1858, and President in 1858 and 1859, and has represented the Society at the Meetings of the American Medical Association several times. 

Doctor Eldredge’s domestic and social relations were of the happiest kind, and his hospitality was proverbial.


Whereas: It has pleased Almighty God to remove from this life, our beloved brother, Dr. James H. Eldredge.

Resolved: that we humbly Submit to the divine decree, which has removed from our midst in the fulness of years and honors a friend who deserved and earned our highest respect and regard.

Resolved: That while we deplore “not as those without hope” the dispensation that severs our connection with one of our worthiest and most esteemed associates, we recognize the merciful provision which preserved to him through a long life of usefulness, his health and power of enjoyment to a very late period and his intellectual powers to the end of his life.

Resolved: that we tender to his surviving family, our warmest sympathy in their bereavement, and our best wishes for their welfare.

If you got to the end of Dr. Turner’s eloquent oratory and understood it, then Eldredge School did its bit. Congratulations are in order for all involved. — AFC

Value the news you get here on East Greenwich News? As a 501-c3, we depend on reader support. Become a sustaining (monthly) donor or make a one-time donation! Click on the Donate button below or send a check to EG News, 18 Prospect St., East Greenwich, RI 02818. Thanks.

Notify of

Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
J. Patlak
J. Patlak
January 8, 2021 10:24 pm

Between this remembrance and Mr. Mastracchio’s recent profile on Dr. Taggart, it’s been lovely reading about the former docs who inhabited and served EG. Thanks!

January 9, 2021 11:49 am

When my family moved to eg in 70s there was a crucifix standing at intersection of middle road and cedar Ave near entrance of the nearby cemtery in honor of dr eldridges apparent rides around town tending to his patients in their homes…unfort resulting from some early form if political correctness that landmark was moved to the nearby cemetery…

Alan clarke
Alan clarke
January 9, 2021 6:17 pm
Reply to  Charles

Yes, the cross was originally at Barton’s Corners but it was moved to the intersection of Middle Road and Cedar Avenue. Right smack dab in the middle of the road, it was. Dr. Eldredge was an Episcopalian and they honored him with a crucifix, not just a cross. A chap of another faith, a newcomer, objected to it being on public property and contacted the ACLU. Rather than fight it, the town chose to move it to private property. In the interim, someone chainsawed it down and removed it. When it was found, they decided to put in in Glenwood Cemetery where it sits today. It’s probably just as well. As it was in the middle of the road, and given the way we drive today, someone would have knocked it down anyway. Thing is, if they had used a medical caduceus instead of a religious symbol, there probably would have been no objection. Religious symbols on public property is a no-no and is constantly tested.

Donna M Horan
Donna M Horan
January 10, 2021 6:55 pm
Reply to  Charles

As I remember the cross, on an island, at the intersection of Middle / Kenyon and Cedar, it was stolen, recovered and then placed inside the cemetery

Judy Stenberg
Judy Stenberg
January 9, 2021 4:03 pm

I am wondering how former East Greenwich educator Amie G. Eldredge was related to this family.

Alan clarke
Alan clarke
January 9, 2021 6:02 pm
Reply to  Judy Stenberg

There were four brothers, Dr, James being one of them. It would be a safe bet that she was the granddaughter or g-g of one of them. Several years back, the Unitarian church razed the old Eldredge manse on Sunset Rock. I surveyed the Eldredge family at that time. I’ll see if I can find it. One brother was in the fuel business, became Eldredge Oil, another had a market in the City and another was a farmer. Don’t quote me though… yet.

alan clarke
alan clarke
January 9, 2021 7:47 pm
Reply to  Judy Stenberg

Dr James Henry Eldredge was Amie Gilbert Eldredge ’s GG Uncle.

Judy Stenberg
Judy Stenberg
January 11, 2021 11:02 am
Reply to  alan clarke

Thank you Alan. Amie was the principal of Hanaford School when I began my teaching career. We did business with Eldredge Oil for years, and our house sits on former Eldredge farm property on Kenyon Avenue. It’s nice to have a connection to such worthy citizens.

Richard Thompson
Richard Thompson
January 10, 2021 9:13 pm

I grew up in the 28 Division St residence from 71 to 94. It was an awesome home. Was always fascinated by his and his father’s history.

Mark Thompson
Mark Thompson
January 13, 2021 12:21 pm

Thanks, Dr. Clarke, for the history lesson. Love reading such “original sources”!


Newsletter Sign Up

* indicates required


Latest Streaming