‘Under God’? Not for This EGHS Student

by | Nov 19, 2014

The Providence Journal has published at least three letters to the editor in recent days from students of Mr. McPartland’s Current American Issues class, including one on littering by Nicole Padrazo and one on moving Election Day to the weekend by Lev Simon.

It was a class assignment: to submit a letter to the editor and see if it gets published.

In Tuesday’s Providence Journal, there was another letter from one of McPartland’s students, this one about the two words “under God” in the Pledge of Allegiance.

Students from kindergarten through 12th grade recite the Pledge of Allegiance every morning, often out of habit. But for senior Noah Barreto, those two words in the pledge – under God – started to sound wrong starting in about eighth grade, he said.

“I was taught to be open to different spiritual possibilities. I’ve met Taoists, Buddists, Jews, Muslims, Hindus, even agnostics,” he said. “I’m not one to tell people what to think but I’m not one to tell people to believe in one god.”

Instead, as he wrote in his letter, “wouldn’t it be more accurate to say, ‘One nation, under infinite gods”?

Barreto is not looking to start a fight. When students recite the Pledge of Allegiance each morning at school, he recites the pledge too, simply omitting those two words.

He is aware the words “under God” were added in 1954. The idea of “God,” per se, isn’t his issue. It’s just that he doesn’t want the pledge limited to one god. And he wants people to think about what they’re saying, no matter what they believe.

“I’m just someone who wants to provoke people to think,” said Barreto. “I’m not hear to impress my beliefs on you. It’s all just about thinking, that’s all it is.”

 

Value the news you get here on East Greenwich News? As a 501-c3, we depend on reader support. Become a sustaining (monthly) donor or make a one-time donation! Click on the Donate button below or send a check to EG News, 18 Prospect St., East Greenwich, RI 02818. Thanks.

4 Comments

  1. Jp3

    This is the way to handle these situations. It should not be a law suit against the school, town, or federal government. If you don’t like it, don’t say it, don’t look at it, create an additional situation that agrees with your beliefs, don’t infringe on others beliefs.

    Reply
  2. Mark Thompson

    Sheesh….had this same issue in Mr. Olson’s homeroom (#240, if memory serves) about 1969.

    Reply
  3. Captain Carl

    Next to the last paragraph; isn’t “per se” what was intended?

    Seeing the photo reminds me when I was in Brookline High School (MA), home room #130, if memory serves. We not only pledged allegiance, we also recited the Lord’s Prayer. If you didn’t want to, nobody said a word about it.
    ’nuff said !

    Reply
    • Elizabeth McNamara

      You’re right about the spelling, Carl – thanks, as always!

      Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

RELATED STORIES

Newsletter Sign Up

* indicates required

Archives

Latest Streaming