RIDE: Schools Can’t Charge Fees for Field Trips. Period

by | Apr 24, 2019

By Elizabeth F. McNamara

In an opinion released to the East Greenwich School Committee this month, State Education Commissioner Ken Wagner said it’s not legal for school districts to charge a fee for school-related field trips.

The opinion strikes at the heart of how East Greenwich has been funding part or all of most school field trips, with at least part of the cost being covered by parents. That comes in the form of a $5 fee to pay for a bus ride to the State House, or a larger fee to cover the cost of a trip to the Pequot Museum in Connecticut, or the $1,200 cost of last year’s 8th grade field trip to Washington D.C.

Under the commissioner’s opinion, all those trips would need to be funded by the school district, though the opinion did leave room for fundraising for school trips, just so long as students weren’t required to meet some sort of quota or specific amount.

The opinion (RIDE EG Field Trip Policy) lays out three ways to fund field trips:

  1. Districts may budget funds for trips, so long as the trip is part of the instructional program and all students have the same ability to attend;
  2. Fundraising for trips is permissible to supplement district budgeted funds, so long as individual students do not have mandated fundraising targets that must be met as a requirement for participation; and
  3. Individuals may be charged fees for a trip, but only for trips that are not organized by the district using district resources, including district-funded staff time.

“I’m proud of the commissioner. The commissioner could have punted and he did the right thing. He did the right thing legally, morally, ethically. And it’s consistent with the law,” said School Committee member Matt Plain. (Commissioner Wagner is leaving his job later this week.)

Four years ago, at his very first meeting as a member of the School Committee, Plain voted against a school-sponsored trip that came with a student price tag. He has continued to vote against all such trips that have come before the committee. After years of discussion about the policy, the committee submitted a request for advisory opinion from the commissioner last September. In absence of a response, the School Committee’s policy subcommittee recently started rewriting the field trip policy.

“I think the policy subcommittee anticipated some of the language here and is working hard to conform to it,” said Committeewoman Lori McEwen. “The policy subcommittee still has work to do.”

Committeewoman Anne Musella, who heads the policy subcommittee, spoke to the fears some parents have expressed about changing the policy. 

She noted that trips taken by Eldredge and Hanaford kids relied on a total of $8,000 in family contributions. At Cole, the Washington D.C. trip cost a total of $121,000 for the 85 students who participated (about a third of the 8th grade class). The total family contribution for all trips at Cole in 2017-18 was $154,000, Musella said.

“The Washington D.C. trip was most of that,” she said. “I don’t want people to panic.”

She added, “I think we all want to make all of it work. I think we just have to define things properly and do it the right way. And ultimately more people may be able to participate. If families are paying anyway, we’re not trying to take anything away. Perhaps the funding can just go through a different mechanism.”

One idea is to let parents know at the beginning of the year that students will be going on X number of trips during the year at a cost of Y, and asking for donations to help cover that cost.

“I think all will become clearer when we get a recommendation from the policy subcommittee. We will get more clarity … when we see the next draft,” said Chairwoman Carolyn Mark.

A roller coaster at the Lake Compounce amusement park in Connecticut.

There were questions raised about end-of-the-year trips at Cole and the high school, like the 8th grade trip to Lake Compounce or Senior Week activities, all of which come with a fee for students. Since the School Committee is only asked to approve overnight trips or trips to noncontiguous states, those end-of-year trips don’t require School Committee approval. But, Plain said, that doesn’t mean they get a pass if they charge a fee.

“Just because it doesn’t come to us, doesn’t mean it’s permissible,” he said.

Others were less comfortable with that stance for trips planned this year well in advance of the commissioner’s opinion.

“I’m not comfortable voting against things that are already in place for the end of the school year,” said Committeeman Jeff Dronzek.

Musella said last year’s trip to Lake Compounce cost families a total of around $9,400 and that she hoped this year’s trip could still happen. Perhaps, she said, the funding mechanisms at the school can be shifted so that there’s no out of pocket cost.”

For Plain, the district was the ultimate winner.

“I’m quite confident that the community will collectively convene to ensure that we keep doing great things,” said Plain. “This is going to be a positive for the district because, for the first time, we’re going to expand learning opportunities to everyone on an equal and non-discriminatory basis…. I’m proud that we’re standing up and we’re going to find a way to continue to offer these expanding learning opportunities in this manner. I’m very happy that we’re doing that.”

The policy subcommittee next meets May 14.

Find more stories about the field trip policy here: 

Field Trip Policy Raises Questions of Equity and Law

Washington D.C. Trip Fails to Gain Approval


East Greenwich News is a nonprofit organization. Help us keep reporting on local issues by clicking on the Donate button below or sending a check to EG News, 18 Prospect St., E.G., RI 02818. Thanks!

Value the news you get here on East Greenwich News? As a 501-c3, we depend on reader support. Become a sustaining (monthly) donor or make a one-time donation! Click on the Donate button below or send a check to EG News, 18 Prospect St., East Greenwich, RI 02818. Thanks.

5 Comments

  1. Carla Swanson

    I appreciate Mr. Plain’s leadership on this issue, and am relieved the Commissioner’s decision makes things very clear-a public education means a free education. That means equitable opportunity for all students when on school time, one of the tenets of public education.

    Reply
  2. christian roos

    not all the districts receive equal funding by the state, therefore nothing is equal here it is just throwing sand in the eyes.
    What is the priority here, a free education or the best possible ( for all ) education ?
    Seems we follow the letter of the ‘law’ and forgetting to improve the education.

    Reply
  3. Disappointed Parent in EG

    I hope everybody realizes that this is not just about field trips. The flood gates have now been opened. Districts will now be on the hook for everything.

    In a couple of weeks students will be taking AP exams. Under this ruling the school district is responsible for the fees for those exams. After doing some research, @ $94 per exam with close to 475 AP exams taken at EGHS last year this would cost the district around $45,000. So if you have a student in an AP class please request the district pay, it is illegal for them to refuse. I know I will not be paying for a single AP exam my child is taking this year and requesting the district pick up the tab.

    In an ACLU press release executive director Steven Brown states “Whatever financial problems a school district may be facing, it is simply wrong to try to resolve them on the backs of students and their families.” While this may be true, I believe that with these added costs schools districts will now be facing they will instead resolve this on the backs of teachers and school staff. I guess the ACLU picks and chooses who they will stand up for now.

    Where is the cutoff?

    Under this ruling I see it as wrong to charge students for a prom ticket, or a calculator for math class. Pens, notebooks, and everyday school supplies should now be paid for by the school, if this will be a true free public education. The internet is a powerful tool in education, should the district have to pay for internet access into every home of students in the district, should computers be supplied completely free of charge? Extracurriculars are covered by this ruling as well. Is the district on the hook for buying sneakers, sticks, cleats, pads, skates, etc?

    I fear that the EG School Committee have opened pandora’s box by requestiing this decision from RIDE. What can we expect the cost of educating a student in EG be now. It feels like we just went from $15,000 to $25,000 per student in the blink of an eye.

    Don’t forget to thank your local EG school committee members when you see them. And if you have been following this story from the beginning you will know specifically who to thank.;-)

    Reply
    • Camille Speca

      Disappointed Parent – AP tests, prom, calculators for math, internet – none of these things are *required*. The district will not pay for these things, nor should they.

      Does it suck? Yes. But now we know and now we can try to take steps to change the law.

      Reply
  4. Happy Parent in EG

    It would be great if someone told that disappointed parent in EG, (although it is pretty easy to guess who it is), to leave town if they are so upset. The lack of compassion and empathy, around understanding the fact that not everyone in this town has the resources to spend on trips is appalling. The fact that this parent would have the audacity to not pay for things when they could as punishment to these people is even worse.

    I applaud the SC for the courage to make all aspects of public school accessible for everyone. Not just the well to do. Keep up the good work.

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published.

RELATED STORIES

Newsletter Sign Up

* indicates required

Archives

Latest Streaming